Guest Stars Jennifer Jason Leigh as Jill Price-Gray Michael Harney as Det. Mitch Ouellette Bruce Nozick as Whit Tillerman Ethan Kent as Stevie Gavin Kent as Stevie Amanda Pace as Taylor Rachel Pace as Shayla Seth Isler as Melnick Karen Strassman as Jolene Waite Jon Collin Barclay as Barton Bailey David Greenman as Wally Amad Jackson as Pierre Co Starring Asher Glaser as Kid in Glasses Jeremy Rabb as Priest Guy Killum as Police Sergeant Madeline Walter as Assistant