Guest Stars James Nuciforo as Jim Nuciforo Staci-Lyn Charles as Morgan Susan Kelechi Watson as Det. Rhonda Buckley Mitch Pileggi as Donald DeCarlo Hemky Madera as Ted Santiago Mlé Chester as Officer Anderson Alberto Rosende as Carlos Santiago Michele Hicks as Cat Holloway Andrea Boehlke as Toweled Girl Nicholas Calhoun as Max Murdock Jennifer Restivo as M.E. Laura Trent Angela Jeanneau as Employee Robin Morse as Phyllis Miller Dominique Huett as Sexy Female Plumber Tiffany Hodges as Alana Robbins Dave Bobb as Angry Man Michael Minarik as Jake Gayley Mia Nuciforo as Mia Chris Lazzaro as Devane Veronica Reyes-How as Gloria Santiago Deborah Twiss as Sheila Gormley Zachary Spicer as Det. Brent Miller Alice Schaerer as Mrs. Rubin Daniel Jenkins as Jerry Phillips Mariann Mayberry as Janice Philips