Guest Stars Armin Shimerman as David Rittenhouse Curtis Caravaggio as Benedict Arnold Damian O'Hare as George Washington Jake Brennan as John Rittenhouse Annie Young as Peggy Arnold Co Starring Marci T. House as Michelle Nathan Dashwood as Continental Soldier Chris Ippolito as Slave Master Brad Dryborough as Earl Cornwallis Joshua Harding as Continental Soldier #2 Naika Toussaint as Slave Woman Conor Gomez as British Officer