Guest Stars Amanda Foreman as Susan Laughlin Kevin West as Gary David Aaron Baker as Grant Nichols Lukas Behnken as Michael Vinoda Elmarie Wendel as Paula Annie B. Compton as Tami Vinoda Co Starring Ava Allan as Erica Nichols Jennifer Riker as Kristen Nichols Mirron E. Willis as Sgt. Potter Joe Peracchio as Otis Meredith Shyloh Oostwald as Cindy Laughlin Adeye Sahran as Grant's Assistant