Guest Stars Ian Bohen as Peter Hale Joey Honsa as Claudia Stilinski Alexander Ward as The Enforcer Michelle Clunie as Mrs. Finch Alisha Boe as Gwen Ryan Malgarini as Trent Co Starring Jennifer Say Gan as Dr. Sandra Hugo Eve Sigall as Old Woman - Grandmother Barry Livingston as David (Businessman) Kevin Will as Tow Truck Driver Luwam Mikael as Pheobe