Special Guest Stars George Michael as Himself Guest Stars Matt Letscher as Nathan Stone Tom Amandes as Martin Posner Tom Cavanagh as Jeremy Stone Jodi Long as Judge Marcia Phelps Pamela Reed as Mrs. Stone Megan Paul as Young Beth Johnny Pacar as Eli, Age 19 John Prosky as Alan Cooke Co Starring Justin Lieberman as Eli, Age 12 Barbara Niven as Mrs. Wethersby Phil Abrams as Larry Conaver Shawn Carter Peterson as Jury Foreperson Paul Ganus as Hurried Man Gokul as Sherpa #1 Natch Narasimhan as Sherpa #2 William Topputo as Ben