Guest Stars Leslie Odom Jr. as Reverend Curtis Scott Josh Pais as Deputy Commissioner Hank Abraham Kecia Lewis as Judge Constance Copeland Jason Cerbone as Terrence Quinn Kirk Acevedo as Eddie Garcia Annaleigh Ashford as Lindsay Anderson Karen Olivo as Yelina Muñoz Lester Holt as Himself Ron Kuby as Himself Vincent Laresca as Alex Muñoz Co Starring Erica Camarano as Officer Rachel Ortiz Joel Brady as Officer Nolan Grace Van Patten as Jodie Lanier James Riordan as Brett Landau Edward Furs as Vlad Julio C. Pena as Aide 1 Therea Woods as Reporter 2 Errol Louis as Reporter 1 Elizabeth Fye as Anna Pretard Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration