Guest Stars Kasha Kropinski as Lisa Potter Alexa Nikolas as Emily Levine Romy Rosemont as Karen Miller Spencer Locke as Brandee Case Lisa Kaminir as School Psychologist Jake Thomas as Eric Miller Scott Alan Smith as Walter Miller Elizabeth Storm as Mrs. Case Michael Holden as Mr. Levine Matteo Crismani as Billy Hopkins Loren Berman as Darren Levine Co Starring Ty Miller as FBI Tech Agent Lauri Hendler as Mrs. Levine Loren Lester as Mr. Roscoe Phil Abrams as Mr. Carr Danielle Rayne as Mrs. Hopkins Zoe Keller as Emily Cohort #1 Matthew Fahey as John Frank Crim as Arcade Manager Taylor Beacom as Frank Potter Tierra Abbott as Girl Keegan Farrell as Emily Cohort #2