Special Guest Stars Stephanie March as Alexandra Cabot Guest Stars Mike Doyle as Forensics Tech Ryan O'Halloran Peter Hermann as Counselor Trevor Langan David Lipman as Judge Arthur Cohen Tonye Patano as Judge Linda Maskin Annie Potts as Sophie Devere Noel Fisher as CSU Tech Dale Stuckey Gail O'Grady as Ruth Walker Mike Pniewski as Ralph Walker Hilary Duff as Ashlee Walker Miriam Colon as Yolanda Deidre Goodwin as Nanny Anastasia Barzee as Monica Stewart Marilyn Torres as Maria Tracy Griswold as Uriah Faber Ryan Raftery as Dennis Faber Tyree Simpson as Cop April Armstrong as Female Reporter #2 Katie McGee as Female Reporter #1 Todd Faulkner as Male Reporter #1 Tim Miller as Clerk Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration