Guest Stars Clare Carey as Mary Bailey Richard Speight, Jr. as Bill Kohler Candace Bailey as Skylar Stevens Timothy Omundson as Phil Constantino David Meunier as Russell Dan Sachoff as Harry Carmichael Dustin Seavey as Teddy "Ted" Williams Erin Daniels as Maggie Ned Bellamy as Deputy Perkins Mandy June Turpin as Arlene Carmichael Scott Michael Morgan as Cop #3 Joseph Bucaro III as Burly Cop Anson Scoville as Cop #1