Guest Stars Isabel Gillies as Kathy Stabler Erin Broderick as Maureen Stabler Jenna Stern as Assistant D.A. Kathleen Eastman Ellen Muth as Elaine Harrington Ben Shenkman as Kenneth Brill Paz de la Huerta as Karen Raye Reed Birney as Harry Waters Siobhan Fallon as Melissa Raye John C. Havens as Johnstone Rita Gardner as Doris Harrington Co Starring Adam LeFevre as Principal Mark Zeisler as McClintock Ray Fitzgerald as F.B.I Agent Schreck Joanne Bayes as Old Woman Angela Bullock as Hammond John Fiske as Pedophile #1 Richard C. Johnson as Pedophile #2 Wally Dunn as Michael Marolo Jeffrey Bean as Wallis Mark Matkevich as Keith Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration