Guest Stars Andrew Terraciano as Sean Reagan Sami Gayle as Nicole "Nicky" Reagan-Boyle Amy Carlson as Linda Reagan Tony Terraciano as Jack Reagan James Nuciforo as Jim Nuciforo Michael T. Weiss as Sonny Malevsky Nick Sandow as Lt. Bello Mike Colter as Cliff Reacher Natalie Knepp as Laura Peck Ezra Knight as Don Sperling Michael J. Burg as Detective Trotta Becky London as Alice O'Brien James Snyder as Billy Coffin John Mainieri as Father Duff John Speredakos as Gerry O'Brien Jordan Lage as Damon Camia Shaun Kevlin as Buchanan Mark Armstrong as Atwater Co Starring Richard Lyntton as German Tourist Camilo Almonacid as Waiter Robert Turano as Captain