Guest Stars Robert Joy as Dr. Sid Hammerback Jamison Jones as Austin Cannon Alan Smyth as Rupert Flannigan Criss Angel as Luke Blade Nick Kiriazis as Prosecutor Co Starring Ashley Rickards as Young Lindsay Monroe Michael McLafferty as Reporter Yuri Brown as Reporter #2 Kelly Connolly as Vienna Hyatt Angie Hill as Jury Forewoman Uncredited Michelle Barkowski as Young Lindsay Monroe's Blonde Friend