Guest Stars Randy Flagler as Firefighter Harold Capp Miranda Rae Mayo as Lieutenant Stella Kidd Robyn Coffin as Cindy Herrmann Jon Seda as Detective Antonio Dawson Amy Morton as Desk Sergeant Trudy Platt Marina Squerciati as Officer Kim Burgess Yaya DaCosta as Nurse April Sexton Elias Koteas as Detective Alvin Olinsky Tom Galantich as John Gallo Matt DeCaro as Sergeant Delaney Co Starring Anthony Ferraris as Squad 3 Driver Tony Ferraris Lauran September as Natasha Rob Wilson as Big Guy Renellè Nicole as Young Woman / Jeannie James R. Doherty as Young Cop Thomas Forde as Victim Erin Allegretti as Waitress Michael A. Dean as Male Officer Vanessa Greenway as Female Partner Carin Silkaitis as Older Woman Nicholas Eyde as Blue Hoodie (Dale) Uncredited Anne Lockhart voices Dispatcher