Guest Stars Peter Mensah as The Hidden One Mark Campbell as George Washington Clancy Brown as Sheriff August Corbin James McDaniel as Ezra Mills Michael O'Keefe as FBI Director Jack Walters Co Starring Jeremy Owens as Headless Horseman Craig Branham as Headless Horseman Janeen Michael as Choir Member #4 Sir Brodie as Priest Vashti Denise Powell as Choir Member #5 Arden Bridget Carrington as Choir Member #3 Karen Batiste as Choir Member #2 Lundyn Ransom as Choir Member #1 Morgan Brown as Church Member #3 Anaya Tention as Church Member #2 Child Kaye Fryburger as Church Member #1 Child Shay Mack as Church Woman Who Screams