Guest Stars Robert John Burke as Ed Tucker Peter Gallagher as Deputy Chief William Dodds Andy Karl as Sergeant Mike Dodds Jonathan Cake as Monsignor Mulregan Michael O'Keefe as Father Eugene O'Hannigan John Ales as Detective Tom Russo Abigail Savage as Nina Kelly J.D. Williams as Detective Anton Jefferson Frank Vincent as Bishop Cattalano Sahr Ngaujah as Father Ankitolah David Cale as Judge Wheeler Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration
