Guest Stars Michael Jai White as Ellis Hays Jim Nantz as Himself Leah Pipes as Jessie Arielle Kebbel as Kat Sharon Madden as Judge Erikson Co Starring Gabriel Salvador as Chris Pontecorvo Brian Tahash as Chuck Spencer Grammer as Sheila Lewis Dauber as Priest Jamie Anderson as Amanda Jeff De Serrano as Uniform Cop Leslie Karpman as Mandy Terasa Livingstone as Jody George Russo as Bail Bondsman Conrad Dunn as Defense Lawyer Ben Kronen as Tailor