Guest Stars William Jackson Harper as Arnold Erin Cummings as Eve Steele Terry Serpico as Willis Sendhil Ramamurthy as Philip Co Starring Lauren Blumenfeld as Barista Deedie Suzy Jane Hunt as Annoyed Customer Natalie Carter as Tourist Michael Gibson as Heavy Guard Charleigh Parker as Fashionable Female Customer Gregory Abbey as Wall Street Guy Kevin Prowse as Plainclothes Cop Garrett Hendricks as Uniform #2 Brian Cross as Luca Georgia Southern as Businesswoman