Special Guest Stars Marilu Henner as Edie Tripp Guest Stars Deanna Dunagan as Alice Wells Derek Cecil as Adam Collier Peter Benson as Father Anselm Kellie Overbey as Erin O'Malley Jack Gwaltney as Sean O'Malley Co Starring Anna Friedman as Katie Monaghan Aaron Sauter as Gregory Smith Mark Zeisler as Attorney Drew McVety as Daniel Monaghan Anna Rose Hopkins as Shannon Spicer Jamil Mena as Ruben Lobato Anne Clare Gibbons-Brown as Hannah