Guest Stars Robert Blanche as Lt. Patrick Bonanno Lisa Schurga as Peggy Milbank Drew Powell as Jack Hurley Sofia Pernas as Sister Lupe Sean Faris as Shelley Russell Hodgkinson as Callaghan Tiago Roberts as Aaron Cortez Brandon Petty as Liam Paul Glazier as Connor Co Starring Lyssa Browne as Janice Mercedes Rose as Female Police Officer Chris DeMaria as Roberto