Guest Stars Riley Smith as Riley Wallace Jessica Parker Kennedy as Megan Rose Trai Byers as Alec Martin Peyton List as Lindsey Beckwith Lindsey McKeon as Suzanne Jason Thompson as Det. Eugene Thompson Sam Daly as Sam Co Starring Whitney Hoy as Katie Maloney Tyler Lepley as Gym Guy Brad Benedict as Announcer Nate Scholz as Hot Firefighter Albert Marrero, Jr. as Police Officer Richie Gaona as Trapeze Instructor