Guest Stars Aaron Abrams as Matthew Weitz François Arnaud as Oscar Trieste Kelly Dunn as Allison Knight Jordana Spiro as Sarah Weller Rosa Arredondo as Camila Solis Maria Rivera as Natalie Remy Auberjonois as Timothy Eavers Neal Matarazzo as Maxwell Tate Wilson Jermaine Heredia as Ronnie Vargas Co Starring Derek Roché as Masked Man Mark Borkowski as Hank Aubin Darren Lipari as Night Employee Ben Greene as Male Lab Tech Meredith Antoian as Woman in Blue Dress Ed Incle as Old Man Joe Burns as Lead Detective Anthony Ferretti as Tall Guard Peter Linari as Overweight Man Lars Gerhard as Head Guard