Guest Stars Lyndsy Fonseca as Olivia Kate Miner as Katie Laurie Metcalf as Susan Hayley Erin as Buttercup #1 Abigail Mavity as Meagan Jasmine Di Angelo as Brittany Kevin Cooney as Dr. Dumont Chanel Gaines as Buttercup #6 Josh Jacobson as Matt Heather McPhaul as Trish Gracie Markland as Buttercup #5 Tiana Danielle Kenney as Buttercup #2 Alyssa Monka as Buttercup #3 Montana Tsai as Buttercup #4