Guest Stars John Capodice as Eric Sasser Barbara Tarbuck as Judge Kaplan Debra Jo Rupp as Florence Herrigan Robert Knepper as Joey D'Amato Sam McMurray as Walter Herrigan Georgann Johnson as Helen Walworth Stephanie Dunnam as Joy D'Amato Warren Frost as Judge Adelman Christina Carlisi as Diana Walworth Joan Darling as Stern Lee Anthony as Unknown Co Starring Terri Ivens as Rhonda Kanaski Megan Cole as Dr. Morris A.J. Freeman as Painter J. Downing as Dwayne Retzik Carl Irwin as Court Clerk