Guest Stars Ashton Holmes as Finn Bailey Michael Irby as Cesar Jones Keelin Woodell as Sarah Renfield Susan Santiago as Det. Solana Ramirez Keisuke Hoashi as Dr. John Chen Travis Hammer as Elijah Hall Gregory Bach as Olsen Courtney Cunningham as Frida Bancroft David Clennon as Marvin Caul Sheila Shaw as Irma Darren Romeo as Romeo the Magician Karen Teliha as Gladys Kayla Crance as Renee Sheffield Olga Pikhienko as Olga the Contortionist Mark Sande as Bill