Guest Stars Michael McGrady as Buchalter Joe Nieves as Fencik Ian Anthony Dale as Detective Christopher Choi Mitch Pileggi as Detective Spivak Jim Beaver as Nick Vukovic Jeanette O'Connor as Motel Receptionist Sara Erikson as Amy Peter Allas as Bookie Gizza Elizondo as Waitress Co Starring Josh Daugherty as Preisser Steven Barr as Hippo Matt Riedy as Father