Guest Stars Jasmin Savoy Brown as Evangeline "Evie" Murphy Bill Heck as Darren Darius McCrary as Isaac Rayney Adina Porter as Guilty Remnant Leader Betty Buckley as Jane Co Starring Kenneth Wayne Bradley as Ranger Bob Turk Pipkin as Pillar Man (Edward) Violett Beane as Taylor Katy Harris as Violet Amy Dionne as Guilty Remnant Member Richard Jackson as Guilty Remnant Man in Glasses Danyelle Cavaness Weatherford as Guilty Remnant Elder 3 Sam Stinson as Dirtbiker Jason Newman as Bus Driver Marissa Luck as Cecilia-Wedding Dress Laurie Coker as Guilty Remant Elder 2 Michael Clossin as Elderly Bartender Josephine McAdam as Whistling Guilty Remnant Girl Gregory Kelly as Guilty Remnant Guard at Gate Kaci Beeler as Waitress Jamie Tisdale as Kristen