Guest Stars Ernie Hudson as Judge Lawrence Perry Shiri Appleby as Emily Adams David Gautreaux as Judge Martin Wilson Carla Gallo as Tammy Setton David Costabile as Richard Taflinger Jake Busey as Dr. Doug A.J. Trauth as Mr. Holman Joshua Erenberg as Young Peter Kimberly Caldwell as Bree Jacqueline Lord as Carina Keller Robert Pierce as Dr. Henkel Julanne Chidi Hill as Jojo Bryson Keyser as Young Jared Co Starring Garrett Ryan as Captain #1 Robert Hooven as Bailiff D. Luke Morgan as Captain #2