Guest Stars Kendrick Sampson as Caleb Hapstall Amy Okuda as Catherine Hapstall Sarah Burns as A.D.A. Emily Sinclair John Posey as William Millstone Matt Cohen as Levi Wescott Enuka Okuma as Nia Lahey Karina Logue as A.D.A. Rita Kaplan Virginia Gardner as Molly Damien Leake as Dr. Healy Sammi Hanratty as Zoey Mitchell