Guest Stars Esau Pritchett as Captain Louis Baptiste Christiani Pitts as Pernessa Reed Paloma Guzmán as Detective Adina Foyle Brandon Espinoza as Detective Garcia Michael Rispoli as Sal Boselli Tony Danza as Stefano Marchetti John Rue as Patrick Burke Frank Carlo as Counter Guy (Giorgio) Jamie Nieto as Demo Michael Leonard James as Pastor Hawkins Damani Varnado as Semrad Lance-Carter Obadiaru as Romero Marlie Hall as Toothy Anchor Liz Larsen as Guidance Counselor Greg Stuhr as Warren Larkin Luis Moreno as Detective Anderson Mike Keller as James Carmody Michael Schantz as Detective Boyd Rich Graff as Detective Durham