Guest Stars Victoria Tate as Rena Robinson Shari Belafonte as Julia Johnson Hannah Leder Werntz as Isabella Joe Marinelli as Donny Eli Bildner as Joel Rapkin Amber Friendly as Layla Bell Tom Irwin as Fred Micklen Joe Pacheco as Bart Choni Francis as RJ Smith Tig Notaro as Amanda Robinson Mindy Kaling as Audra Natalie Morales as Kate Danton Clive Standen as Andre Ford Shannon Woodward as Jess Bennett Co Starring Jamal Lloyd Johnson as Preston Ricky Titus-Lam as Baker 2 Jerome Beck as Baker 1 Kelli Scates as Photographer