Guest Stars Gary Cole as Gordon Novel Steven Williams as Alan Sanborn Seamus Dever as Andy the German J. Smith-Cameron as Lois Roden Eric T. Esparza as Joe Turner Mark Speno as Doug Tinker Matthew Menalo as Rocket Rosen Kieran Mulcare as Terry Nichols Michael Vincent Berry as George Roden Paul Dillon as Pappy Millar Giorgia Whigham as Becca Whitsett Annika Marks as Kathy Schroeder Co Starring Mimi Fletcher as Jury Forewoman Lori Rae Nicholas Kolev as Paul Fatta Cassie Dzienny as Jocelyn Bryant Ryan de Quintal as Militia Man Arianne Martin as Bonnie Haldeman Mark Sipka as Sales Clerk Jeff Pride as ATF Expert Sale Taylor as Gun Dealer Eddie Garcia as Reporter #1 Caleb Horst as Defense Paralegal Laila Phillips as Kayla Gram Carly Lepard as US Marshall Steve Sladaritz as Lt. Matt Caldwell Tim Misuradze as Austin Boak Colin Jones as Sheriff Dickerson Diana Gaitirira as Reporter #2 Credit Only Shea Whigham as Mitch Decker John Leguizamo as Jacob Vasquez