Guest Stars J.B. Smoove as Luke Nick Robinson as Robert Todd Lincoln Ike Barinholtz as General Ulysses S. Grant Jay Ellis as Jesus Christ Richard Kind as Peter Zahn McClarnon as Private Mingoes Ronny Chieng as Kublai Khan Tyler James Williams as Private Mason Dixon Zazie Beetz as Mary Magdalene Nick Kroll as Judas Tim Baltz as Lieutenant Henry Honeybeard Quinta Brunson as Martha Magdalene Ike Barinholtz as Mark Hannah Einbinder as Amelia Earhart Jason Alexander as Maurice Cheeks Wanda Sykes as Gloria Wanda Sykes as Bessie Coleman Nick Kroll as Steven Santelmo Jack McBrayer as General Robert E. Lee Ike Barinholtz as Barry Santelmo Co Starring Katherine LaVeaux as TBD Josh Meyers as General Philip Sheridan Edgar Blackmon as Apostle Margaret Cho as Sophia Bobby Lee as Harold Guy Branum as Union Private Kulap Vilaysack as Jennifer Alana Rosenbloom as Samantha "Raven" Santelmo