Guest Stars Audrey Corsa as Rebecca Tim Meadows as Michael Graves Chris McKinney as Phil Jameela Jamil as Ava Ellen Barkin as Kathleen Townsend Niall Cunningham as Harry Co Starring Ben Sinclair as Boss William Hill as Sheriff Ed Noah Crandell as Assistant Brad Calcaterra as Chef Sarah Marie Jenkins as Deborah Franklin Rony Clanton as Patron Adam Enright as Jeremy Julian Alvarez as Male Chorus John Edward Miller as Buzz Roger Hendricks Simon as Bernie Cameron Hah as Female Chorus Robert Ariza as Ben Franklin