Special Guest Stars Adam DeVine as Andy Bailey Guest Stars Reid Ewing as Dylan Marshall Laura Ashley Samuels as Beth Jeremy Scott Johnson as Andrew Matt McGrath as Simon Co Starring Spenser McNeil as Reuben Michele Panu as Sarah Ho Brooke Sorenson as Tammy Shanna Strong as Laughing Girl Johnny Ray Meeks as Theater Goer Jill Remez as Hostess Marissa Caprielian as Customer