Special Guest Stars Molly Burnett as Detective Grace Muncy Guest Stars Aida Turturro as Judge Felicia Catano Frances Turner as Elaine Samuels Anthony Patellis as Judge Lonnie Dukakis Julia Goldani Telles as Kelsey Jones Dana Wheeler-Nicholson as Lilah Jones Tony Ward as Joe Boyer Grant Anstine as Austin Boyer Co Starring Vivian Cabell as Jesse Murphy Rollins Dawn Yanek as Reporter Beatrice Mallow as Billie Rollins Ashley Taylor Greaves as Officer Gabrielle Taylor Hope Blackstock as Reporter Anthony M. Walker as Malique Alison Cimmet as Dr. Hannah Rosenthal David Jennings as Randy Tony Melson as Max Carter Dulita Northrop as Jury foreperson Kennebrew Taylor as Female Fan Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration