Guest Stars Bree Elrod as Jennifer Ferguson Co Starring Mila Harris as Young Karen Broberg Elle Lisic as Young Susan Broberg Wyatt Parker as Jasper Berchtold Tyler Wojton as Joel Berchtold Jace Millican as Jacob Berchtold Keilah Davies as Young Caroline Hansen Ed Wagenseller as Bob Eldridge Megan McFarland as Mrs. Brink Todd Sheeler as Ed Stephens