Guest Stars James Pizzinato as Suzy's Dad Everett Andres as Mike Apple Co Starring Jarrett John as Orville Nevin Burkholder as Rhodes / Bartender Liza Huget as Mrs. Cunningham Zoë Noelle Baker as Jolene Paul Anthony as Jim Tom / Drunk Man Everick Golding as Herb Gilly / Bar Owner Isabel Birch as Suzy William Carson as Billy (4 years old)