Guest Stars Tuc Watkins as Colin McKenna Jai Rodriguez as Jonathan #2 Colin Hanlon as Jonathan #1 Co Starring Jasai Chase Owens as Kai April Ortiz as Teresa Gonzalo Aburto de la Fuente as Wyatt Ka-Ling Cheung as Wedding Planner Adam Harper as Craig Brady Adair as Phillip Elise Rovinsky as Wedding Rabbi Corey Mach as Danny Weaver