Guest Stars Will Swenson as Sebastian Fairmont Jonas Dylan Allen as Ben Wheeler Christopher B. Duncan as Principal Cyrus Waters Co Starring Gail Soltys as Phillipa Calhoun Roberto Méndez as Noah Harrington Annunziata Gianzero as Bunny Wheeler Emmanuel Wood as Young Theo Brooke Jaye Taylor as Detective Morse David Shae as Detective Lee Archith Seshadri as Ritvik Dhavale Jennifer Yun as Reporter 3 Africa Miranda as Reporter 1 Diana Lovell as M.A.A.M. Member Natalie Hendrix Tate as Katie Savage Daniel Pera as Mark Shayla Harris as Theo's Mom