Guest Stars Boris McGiver as Monsignor Matthew Korecki Molly Brown as Leslie Anthony DeSando as Father Rodrigo Katagas Jack Berenholtz as Bobby Madeline Wise as Jessica Malachy Cleary as Pastor Phil Nowell James Cusati-Moyer as Matthew Darius Fraser as Oliver Gabriela Torres as Kelly Bennington Alexander Molina as Emergency Worker #2 Thomas Silcott as Kevin Messersmith Dipti Mehta as Nurse Abbas Dennis Creaghan as Father Gray Tanya Perez as Emergency Worker #1 David Lansbury as Father Barnaby Miche Braden as Adina Philip Hoffman as Rabbi Gary Bockman Uncredited Patrick Brammall as Andy Bouchard