Special Guest Stars Shantel VanSanten as Special Agent Nina Chase Guest Stars Taylor Anthony Miller as Kelly Moran Vedette Lim as Elise Taylor James Chen as Ian Lim Roshawn Franklin as Special Agent Trevor Hobbs Mara Davi as Samantha Kelton Ben Shenkman as Assistant Director in Charge Reynolds Mlé Chester as Linda Viola Laura Shoop as Nancy O'Connor Micah Scroggins as Clayton Hall Scot Wade Cain as Zach O'Connor John Patrick Hayden as Jack O'Connor Co Starring Caleb Reese Paul as Tyler Kelton Anthony E. Williams as SWAT Team Leader Adam Monley as Mark Whitman Michael Dean Morgan as Ryan Bell Will Blomker as Robert Hall David Wenzel as Jeremy Brosnihan Charlë Webb as Local Cop John Toon as Ted Whitman Jessie Hooker-Bailey as Emily Fallin John Noble Barrack as Man Lauren Hines as Allison Hall AJ Dyer as Simon Branch