Guest Stars Jennifer Landon as Sarah Allen Glenn Fleshler as Caleb Walsh Christian Campbell as Daniel Osterholm Josh Clark as Homer Courtland Ross DeGraw as Matt Lewis Melissa Maxwell as Beth Carey Rashad Edwards as Joe Milica Govich as Michelle Walsh Andrew Kai as Craig Osterholm Co Starring Shaun Woodland as Officer Tyler Bob Ari as Tucker Kara Rosella as Jeanine Osterholm Alex Walton as Mason Izabel Mar as Aubrey Laurie Wells as Laine Osterholm Kelley Heyer as Darcy Osterholm