Guest Stars Chau Long as Steve Bill Kottkamp as Derrick Michael Angarano as Greg Carlease Burke as Minister Eve Jordan Gavaris as Jay Devon Graye as Roger Shannyn Covington as Karina Blair Beeken as Neighbor #1 Ravi Sinha Smith as Sean Alfred Adderly as Brett's Dad Christina Ogunade as Brett's Mom Ani Sava as Frances Heather Wynters as Neighbor #2 Brayden Fenderson as Brett Savanah Gow as Sean's Friend Sarah Guadron as Brett's Friend