Guest Stars Tony Espinosa as Jafeer Anna Pniowsky as Heather Sami Rappoport as Becca Jessica Pressley as Jessica Hannah Mae as Connie M. Chau Long as Steve Marion Van Cuyck as Terra Newback Brandon Keener as Mr. O Harvey J. Alperin as Rabbi Alison Martin as Sandra Pete Handelman as Eugene (Becca's Dad) Jesse James D'Angelo as Party Dancer #1 Michele Karpel as Lenore Noëlle Lara as Party Dancer #2 Meryl Lester as Party Dancer #3