Special Guest Stars Marcia Gay Harden as Maggie Brener Valeria Golino as Paola Lambruschini Mindy Kaling as Audra Guest Stars Victoria Tate as Rena Robinson Shari Belafonte as Julia Johnson Hannah Leder Werntz as Isabella Eli Bildner as Joel Rapkin Amber Friendly as Layla Bell Tom Irwin as Fred Micklen Michelle Meredith as Lindsey Jack Conley as Earl Katie Aselton as Madeleine Hasan Minhaj as Eric Nomani David Paymer as Mr. Shoenfeld Co Starring Theo Iyer as Kyle Choni Francis as RJ Smith Aflamu Johnson as Aflamu Candice Ramirez as Jasmyn Stephen Friedrich as Jeffrey Gordon Marisa Echeverria as Robin Brad Lee Wind as Kenny Casey Adams as NY Pedestrian