Guest Stars Nick Offerman as Lt. Chance Briggs Jordan Peele as Dr. Brian David Wain as Rabbi Jewy McJewJew Paul Scheer as Sir Tinklebutton James Adomian as Madonna Christina Chang as Duenna Lindsay Sloane as Roxanne Cheryl Tiegs as Herself Karthik Srinivasan as Dev Madeline Walter as Waitress George Cheng as Old Man Shaifali Ratti as Nidhi