Guest Stars Emily Davis as Sue Herlitz Namir Smallwood as Frank Deluca Dallas Roberts as Jackson Berg Jim True-Frost as Pete Novick Caitlin Houlahan as Christy Joanne Tucker as Pam Novick Co Starring Caitlin Cavannaugh as Joelle Jeremy Denzlinger as Offinger Bill Laing as Rylan Rick Dutrow as Nolan Danek Tali Rabinowitz as Katie Danek Riley Baron as Jimbo Connelly Tristan Borders as Pete Novick, Jr. Will F. Moore as Head Coach Dooley Shay Guthrie as Connie Henry Thrasher as Keith Caroline Collins as Phyllis Danek Emily Peachey as Shonie