Guest Stars Amy Morton as Desk Sergeant Trudy Platt Stella Maeve as Nadia Decotis Josh Segarra as Justin Voight Co Starring Alina Taber as Lexi Olinsky Don Forston as Phil Rodiger Matthew Sherbach as Lonnie Rodiger Frank Meo as Paramedic Howie Johnson as Sgt. Conroy Lucas Marx as Brayden Marvin Cruz as Bouncer Michael McCracken as John Brendan Samuel Sullivan as Gareth Evans Kevin Michael Doyle as Commander Steve Burtt Alexis J. Rogers as Principal Brenner Tim Vaughn as Glenn Ward R. Charles Wilkerson as Pastor Mike Tara Mallen as Renee Evans Tom Hickey as Secret Service Agent Joe Hill Steve O'Connell as Dean Masters Molly Pan as Lissa Paige Smith as Adam Mazur