Guest Stars Alex Collins voices Dr. Charles McNider / Dr. Mid-Nite Joel McHale as Sylvester Pemberton / Starman Ysa Penarejo as Jennie Scott Milo Stein as Young Bruce Olive Elise Abercrombie as Rebecca McNider Co Starring Gilbert Glenn Brown as James Chapel Kron Moore as Dr. Bridget Chapel Stella Smith as Artemis Crock Kay Galvin as Lily Mahkent Jim France as Sofus Mahkent King Orba as Zeek Max Frantz as Isaac Bowin Deborah Bowman as Miss Woods Kenny Alfonso as Father Thomas Tywayne Wheatt as Principal Harold Sherman Emily Dunlop as Myra McNider